One-Group Posttest Only Design: An Introduction
The one-group posttest-only design (a.k.a. one-shot case study ) is a type of quasi-experiment in which the outcome of interest is measured only once after exposing a non-random group of participants to a certain intervention.
The objective is to evaluate the effect of that intervention which can be:
- A training program
- A policy change
- A medical treatment, etc.
As in other quasi-experiments, the group of participants who receive the intervention is selected in a non-random way (for example according to their choosing or that of the researcher).
The one-group posttest-only design is especially characterized by having:
- No control group
- No measurements before the intervention
It is the simplest and weakest of the quasi-experimental designs in terms of level of evidence as the measured outcome cannot be compared to a measurement before the intervention nor to a control group.
So the outcome will be compared to what we assume will happen if the intervention was not implemented. This is generally based on expert knowledge and speculation.
Next we will discuss cases where this design can be useful and its limitations in the study of a causal relationship between the intervention and the outcome.
Advantages and Limitations of the one-group posttest-only design
Advantages of the one-group posttest-only design, 1. advantages related to the non-random selection of participants:.
- Ethical considerations: Random selection of participants is considered unethical when the intervention is believed to be harmful (for example exposing people to smoking or dangerous chemicals) or on the contrary when it is believed to be so beneficial that it would be malevolent not to offer it to all participants (for example a groundbreaking treatment or medical operation).
- Difficulty to adequately randomize subjects and locations: In some cases where the intervention acts on a group of people at a given location, it becomes infeasible to adequately randomize subjects (ex. an intervention that reduces pollution in a given area).
2. Advantages related to the simplicity of this design:
- Feasible with fewer resources than most designs: The one-group posttest-only design is especially useful when the intervention must be quickly introduced and we do not have enough time to take pre-intervention measurements. Other designs may also require a larger sample size or a higher cost to account for the follow-up of a control group.
- No temporality issue: Since the outcome is measured after the intervention, we can be certain that it occurred after it, which is important for inferring a causal relationship between the two.
Limitations of the one-group posttest-only design
1. selection bias:.
Because participants were not chosen at random, it is certainly possible that those who volunteered are not representative of the population of interest on which we intend to draw our conclusions.
2. Limitation due to maturation:
Because we don’t have a control group nor a pre-intervention measurement of the variable of interest, the post-intervention measurement will be compared to what we believe or assume would happen was there no intervention at all.
The problem is when the outcome of interest has a natural fluctuation pattern (maturation effect) that we don’t know about.
So since certain factors are essentially hard to predict and since 1 measurement is certainly not enough to understand the natural pattern of an outcome, therefore with the one-group posttest-only design, we can hardly infer any causal relationship between intervention and outcome.
3. Limitation due to history:
The idea here is that we may have a historical event, which may also influence the outcome, occurring at the same time as the intervention.
The problem is that this event can now be an alternative explanation of the observed outcome. The only way out of this is if the effect of this event on the outcome is well-known and documented in order to account for it in our data analysis.
This is why most of the time we prefer other designs that include a control group (made of people who were exposed to the historical event but not to the intervention) as it provides us with a reference to compare to.
Example of a study that used the one-group posttest-only design
In 2018, Tsai et al. designed an exercise program for older adults based on traditional Chinese medicine ideas, and wanted to test its feasibility, safety and helpfulness.
So they conducted a one-group posttest-only study as a pilot test with 31 older adult volunteers. Then they evaluated these participants (using open-ended questions) after receiving the intervention (the exercise program).
The study concluded that the program was safe, helpful and suitable for older adults.
What can we learn from this example?
1. work within the design limitations:.
Notice that the outcome measured was the feasibility of the program and not its health effects on older adults.
The purpose of the study was to design an exercise program based on the participants’ feedback. So a pilot one-group posttest-only study was enough to do so.
For studying the health effects of this program on older adults a randomized controlled trial will certainly be necessary.
2. Be careful with generalization when working with non-randomly selected participants:
For instance, participants who volunteered to be in this study were all physically active older adults who exercise regularly.
Therefore, the study results may not generalize to all the elderly population.
- Shadish WR, Cook TD, Campbell DT. Experimental and Quasi-Experimental Designs for Generalized Causal Inference . 2nd Edition. Cengage Learning; 2001.
- Campbell DT, Stanley J. Experimental and Quasi-Experimental Designs for Research . 1st Edition. Cengage Learning; 1963.
Further reading
- Understand Quasi-Experimental Design Through an Example
- Experimental vs Quasi-Experimental Design
- Static-Group Comparison Design
- One-Group Pretest-Posttest Design
Become a Matador in Fall 2025
Discover CSUN and start crafting your success story today !
Your Future Starts Here
Live Matador Life to the Fullest
Whether you’re looking to join a student club and take part in activities outside of the classroom or if you're just looking for someone who you can connect with, you can find it here.
Research opportunities can be absolutely critical and transformative for students. Akemi Hinzer ’21, Biochemistry
Regardless of where you come from... it's ultimately up to you to show up. Yahya Kedir, Senior, Systems and Operations Management
[CSUN was] eye opening… I discovered things about myself that I didn’t know. Keyly Sandoval ’24, Family and Consumer Sciences
At CSUN I developed the skills and passion for biomedical research... I am forever proud and thankful to be a Matador alumnus! Malachia Y. Hoover ’17, M.S. Biology
You Belong at CSUN
Diversity, equity, inclusion and justice is at the core of CSUN's values. We're committed to a campus culture where everyone feels valued and engaged.
Resources To Cultivate a Sense of Belonging
Learn how Matadors connect and thrive during their academic journey.
Prioritize Your Well-Being for a Successful Semester
Explore CSUN's Counseling Services for support.
Empower Your Journey with Inclusive Support
Discover CSUN's Disability Resources and Educational Services.
CSUN Newsroom
October 23, 2024
Remembering Dorothy Wood Lawson, Pioneer of Integration & Civil Rights Movement
Longtime civil rights activist Dorothy Wood Lawson died in early September, just three months following the ...
October 22, 2024
Can Gen Z Achieve the American Dream? A CSUN Marketing Professor Weighs In
The house, the white picket fence, multiple kids and the garage to hold the two cars. This, as cliche as it m...
How to Vote Out Election Stress: Both On and Off Campus
With the 2024 election inching closer and closer, and with two starkly different versions of American governm...
CSUN Events
Time: 3:00pm - 10:00pm Location: Chicano House Lawn
Time: 10:00am - 3:00pm Location: NEW LOCATION!! Nordhoff Street Access Road (South Side of Campus in front of the Soroya) between Lindley and Etiwanda Avenues
Time: 8:00am - 12:00pm Location: The Younes and Soraya Nazarian Center for the Performing Arts | Zev Yaroslavsky Rehearsal Room
COMMENTS
An important drawback of pre-experimental designs is that they are subject to numerous threats to their validity. Consequently, it is often difficult or impossible to dismiss rival hypotheses or explanations. Therefore, researchers must exercise extreme caution in interpreting and generalizing the results from pre …
The One-Shot Case Study. The one-shot case study design is shown in figure 4.1e. It is also called the ex post facto design because a single group of people is measured on some dependent variable after an intervention has taken place.
one-shot case study. a research design in which a single group is observed on a single occasion after experiencing some event, treatment, or intervention. Because there …
The purpose of this article is to describe single-case studies, and contrast them with case studies and randomized clinical trials. We will highlight current research designs, analysis …
1. One-Shot Case Study Design a. Also called the one group posttest-only design, the one-shot case study design has only one group, a treatment, and a posttest. Because there is only one …
validity is the one-group posttest-only design, which is also called the one-shot case study (Campbell & Stanley, 1966). Using the one-group posttest-only design, a researcher measures …
One-shot case study One-group pre-test and post-test design Static-group comparison. What is “One-shot case study?”